I do a lot of reviews here. I give you my straight opinion on books I have read. Ya’ll know I am always honest when it comes to what I think about that.
But I’ve never told you not to read a book that I HAVEN’T read. In general, I don’t think that is my place. Not on this website. I will often share things on twitter other people have said, and take place in discussions there. But this is a place for book reviews.
I know it is. But this can’t stand.
We’ve known for awhile that Carve the Mark by Veronica Roth was going to be problematic. The blurbs sounded bad. Then those who had ARCs started pulling things out and we all realized just how racist this book was.
If you haven’t been paying attention, Carve the Mark is a sort of Romeo and Juliet story, where one family is light and peaceful and the other is violent and dark-skinned. Yes, it is THAT kind of trope. The Shotet have kinky hair, while the Thuve have straight hair. The Shotet carve actual marks in their arms when they kill people, and are seen as barbaric. (For more information, see Justina Ireland’s excellent analysis of The Continent and Carve the Mark. She writes so much more eloquently on this subject than I can.)
All of that was reason enough to not read this book, or so you’d think. Still, we continued to see tons of promotion for it, and bloggers excited to read it. Instagram is filled with pictures of the cover–which, I agree, at first is stunning, but now just cuts every time I see it.
We didn’t think it could get worse, but last night an interview surfaced from VR on NPR. Here is a screenshot.
So not only is this book extremely racist, but it is ableist too! Horribly so. And STILL this book is being promoted. Money over People every damn day.
If you have never felt the pain of a chronic illness, I want you to listen closely to what I describe next. And then I want you to go to your Goodreads and take this horrid book off of your TBRs. Or put it on your DO NOT READ list. Stop putting this wretched book on your Instagram and your Twitter and Snapchat and Booktube. The POC and Spoonies don’t want to see it. We don’t want to read it. And the more marketing we give books like this, the more encouragement we give the publishing houses to continue to put out toxic work, instead of diverse, Own Voices stories that encourage and lift and properly represent.
So Veronica Roth, please, tell me how my chronic, debilitating migraines are a gift. Explain to me how I should be grateful for pain so bad it blinds me.
It’s pain so bad I cannot sleep or handle any light at all. All I want to do is scream but I can’t do that either because NOISE IS FORBIDDEN
It’s pure panic because OH MY GOD I AM GOING TO DIE MY HEAD IS LITERALLY GOING TO EXPLODE THIS TIME OH MY GOD PLEASE JUST MAKE IT STOP.
And then, OH AND THEN, when you try to explain it to some one they say “Oh, yeah, I get headaches a lot too. Just take an advil.”
So no. Being a Spoonie isn’t a GIFT. I don’t consider myself blessed to have chronic migraines.
I am, however, blessed to have good medical insurance, and a great support system. Many spoonies aren’t that lucky, and it’s about to get much much worse.
So you can go to hell with your book.
Fellow Spoonies, our pain is not a gift. But, WE ARE A GIFT. EVERY SINGLE ONE OF YOU IS A GIFT. I love every single one of you.
I want to update this, since VR did an interview after last night’s criticisms came out. She spoke a bit, clarifying that her MC isn’t always strong, that she does rely on certain medical care and support systems in the book. However, she also blamed the interviewer and did not take full responsibility for what she said. If she truly has a chronic illness, then I am sorry that it came out when she didn’t want it to–but it feels a little defensive.
Either way, the interview does not resolve the problematic nature of the book. It is still harmful to those who suffer chronic pain and illness. And she did not address the racism at all, and that is a very real issue that many people are overlooking today. No matter how you slice it, Carve the Mark is an incredibly harmful book that should never have made it through publishing, no matter who the author is. Authors can write both good books and bad books. This one is a BAD BOOK, and people need to understand why. We cannot just follow authors blindly–they are not gods, they are mortal. Unless we have discussions like this, unless we take them off their pedestal, issues like racism and ableism will never be resolved.
For further reading: Check out the #NotAGift hashtag on twitter. There are amazing people sharing amazing stories there. Please listen to them. Share them. We are going back to a healthcare system where Spoonies are going to lose their medical coverage. This is #NotAGift.